On the season finale of Farmer Wants a Wife, Joe had to choose between Keely and Sarah.
He admitted to the cameras that he was nervous about making the wrong decision, and he said that he would break someone’s heart if he made the wrong choice.
Ultimately, he chose Sarah because she was the one who knew what she was getting into when it came to being a farm wife.
The show also showed a very telling sign that the pair didn’t make it past that moment.
During the second half of the episode, we saw Joe preparing for his friend Andrew’s wedding, which was to be held in season 11.
However, Sarah was unable to attend due to a “prior commitment.” This caused a huge uproar among fans.
It’s possible that Sarah and Joe’s relationship ended following the wedding of Andrew and Jess, which took place in March.
Since they were both featured in the same episode, producers might not want to make it clear that they had broken up.
One of the users on Instagram claimed that Sarah’s prior commitment was the reason why she and Joe didn’t make it past the reunion.
They stated that if she had left, it would have ruined the suspense of who he would choose to be his wife.
According to others, the couple didn’t make it past the reunion, which was filmed around a month after filming wrapped.
An insider claimed that the couple had already suffered from major issues before the reunion, and they haven’t seen each other in a couple of weeks.
Joe reportedly started flirting with the other farm wives on the show.