One Nation Vows to Strip Gender Identity Protections From Victorian Law as Liberals Confirm Preference Deal With Hanson’s Party Just Days Before State Election
- One Nation’s Victorian deputy leader Colleen Harkin says the party will rewrite the Equal Opportunity Act to put biological sex ahead of gender identity if it wins power on November 28.
- The plan would reserve bathrooms, change rooms, prisons, shelters and family violence refuges for biological females, and restrict female sport categories in state-funded competitions.
- Liberal leader Jess Wilson has confirmed preferences will flow to One Nation on a case-by-case basis, after weeks of avoiding the question.
- LGBTIQA+ advocates warn trans Victorians fleeing violence could be turned away from refuges in a state with only two dedicated LGBTIQA+ family violence beds.
With less than a fortnight until Victorians vote, one of the most divisive questions in Australian politics has landed at the centre of the state campaign.
Pauline Hanson’s One Nation has spelt out what it would do with power in Victoria. It would rewrite the state’s anti-discrimination law to restore what it calls biological definitions of men and women.
Supporters say the change would protect women and girls. Opponents say it would strip legal protection from one of the state’s most marginalised groups.
The commitment came from Colleen Harkin, deputy leader of One Nation’s Victorian branch. She said her party would correct policies that, in her words, “ignore biological reality” if it is elected on November 28.
The centrepiece is a rewrite of Victoria’s Equal Opportunity Act that would put a person’s sex at birth ahead of their gender identity across legislation, government policy and day-to-day practice.
Ms Harkin set out the scope of the plan.
Any women-only space that relies on state funding or regulation, from public toilets and locker rooms to jails, crisis shelters and family violence refuges, would be open only to people born female.
The plan extends to sport.
In sport, the rule would reach from elite leagues down to Saturday morning netball: if a competition takes taxpayer money or plays on government-owned grounds, its women’s divisions would exclude anyone not born female.
Ms Harkin argued that the current law allows men who identify as women into female-only spaces. In her view that erodes protections around safety, privacy and a level playing field that earlier generations of women fought hard to secure.
She vowed One Nation would put a stop to what she labelled “extremist insanity”.
Turning to sport, Ms Harkin argued that fair competition is the whole point, and that it is unjust for female athletes to face rivals who went through male puberty.
The announcement came during Transgender Awareness Week, and critics say the timing was deliberate.
The announcement also coincided with a major shift on the right of Victorian politics. Liberal leader Jess Wilson, who had avoided questions about preferences for weeks, confirmed the party would direct preferences to One Nation.
She said the decisions would be made case by case, depending on the views of individual candidates. That leaves open the question of whether Liberal preferences could help elect candidates who back the policy.
The debate did not start this year. Since 2013, transgender and gender-diverse Australians have been protected from discrimination on the basis of gender identity under federal law.
Victoria’s Equal Opportunity Act 2010 provides similar protection at state level.
Pressure to wind those protections back grew sharply after the case between transgender woman Roxanne Tickle and Sall Grover, founder of the women-only social app Giggle for Girls.
The dispute began in 2021. Ms Tickle was removed from the platform after submitting a selfie to an app that used facial recognition software to sort users by gender presentation.
Ruling in Ms Tickle’s favour, the judge held that removing her from the app on the basis of how her gender presented amounted to unlawful discrimination by Ms Grover and her company.
Ms Grover tried to take the matter to the High Court of Australia. In September, that final attempt failed.
Since then, conservative commentators and activists have campaigned to remove gender identity protections from anti-discrimination law. They argue the protections come at the expense of women and girls.
One Nation’s Victorian platform is the most concrete version of that campaign so far.
Analysis: What This Means for Australia
The policy goes well beyond the culture wars. It affects frontline services, the justice system and Victoria’s family violence crisis.
The biggest practical risk is in family violence refuges. Victoria’s landmark family violence royal commission reported that trans women suffer abuse from partners more often than lesbian, gay and bisexual people who are not trans.
Its recommendations included tightening the legislation to make sure no refuge or support service could turn trans Victorians away. One Nation’s plan would move in the opposite direction.
The evidence on public facilities also cuts against the policy’s central claim. In March, the Australian Human Rights Commission released its Equal Identities report.
That review could not find anything to show that letting trans people use the facilities matching their identity makes toilets or change rooms less safe for others.
If anything, it concluded, it is trans women and non-binary Australians who are more likely to be abused or attacked in those spaces.
The plan also raises questions about enforcement. Critics ask how facilities would check biological sex at a public toilet, a women’s shelter or a junior netball registration desk.
No enforcement mechanism has been outlined.
There is also a constitutional problem. Federal anti-discrimination law would still protect gender identity regardless of what Victoria legislates.
That could leave councils, sporting clubs and service providers caught between conflicting state and federal obligations.
The Victorian Pride Lobby condemned the proposal. The group branded the party’s rhetoric towards trans and gender diverse Victorians as abhorrent, warning the plan would unwind equality gains that took decades to win.
Co-convenor Gregory Storer said safety was a right for every Victorian, women and girls included. Stripping gender identity out of anti-discrimination law, he cautioned, would leave trans and gender diverse people far more exposed to being shut out and mistreated.
Rather than setting at-risk communities against each other, he argued, the answer was to boost family violence support across the board.
He pointed out that the entire state has just two refuge beds set aside for LGBTIQA+ people escaping violence, and said One Nation’s response would make it even harder for trans Victorians to find help.
Taking rights away from one group does nothing to protect women, Mr Storer said, adding that real safety comes from proper funding, decent services and mutual respect.
The lobby has called on every party in the Victorian Parliament to reject the proposal.
Legal observers note that any state amendment would have to be squared with Commonwealth law, which they expect to produce drawn-out legal challenges.
Family violence sector insiders warn that refuges already turning people away for lack of space can ill afford new eligibility tests or new legal risk.
Political analysts believe the policy is aimed at voters drawn to One Nation’s broader message. They say the Liberal preference deal, however carefully worded, ties the alternative government to the controversy.
For the trans Victorians at the centre of the debate, the result on November 28 could decide whether the law still protects them when they seek help.
Support is available 24/7. Call Lifeline on 13 11 14, QLife on 1800 184 527, Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636, or Kids Helpline on 1800 55 1800.
