‘What Is a Man?’ Leaked Coalition Scripts Reveal Candidates Drilled on Gender Wars, Grocery Prices and the Scandals Haunting Jess Wilson’s Victorian Campaign
- Secret daily briefings from Coalition headquarters tell Victorian candidates to answer the question “What is a man?” with three words: “A biological male.”
- Hopefuls carry cheat sheets listing the price of eggs, milk and petrol so they never repeat the infamous grocery gaffes of Anthony Albanese and Peter Dutton.
- Candidates have been warned that rival party volunteers may be secretly recording them at early voting booths.
- The scripts include rehearsed lines on disendorsed Williamstown candidate Paul Lindemann and a racist tirade by a volunteer in Dandenong.
Every word is weighed. Every answer is pre-written.
Every candidate is told to assume someone is filming.
With Victorians days away from deciding who governs the state, a cache of leaked internal documents has revealed how tightly the Liberal-National Coalition is controlling its candidates.
Even the most basic exchanges with voters at a polling booth are scripted.
The question is no longer simply who will win the Victorian election. It is how far a party will go to stop its own people from saying something they shouldn’t.
The documents, first obtained by The Age, are daily “talking points” sent from the Coalition’s campaign headquarters to its candidates. They cover hot-button social questions, kitchen-table economics and the scandals that have already rattled Opposition Leader Jess Wilson’s bid for power.
The first briefing landed in candidates’ inboxes on November 18. That was the day after Wilson called for a review of puberty blockers prescribed through Victoria’s public health system.
Under a heading flagging the “issues of the day”, candidates were told how to respond if a voter asked them to define a man. The approved answer was “a biological male.”
They were also prepared for questions about where transgender people should get changed. The script says the Coalition has no plan to swap gendered facilities for gender-neutral toilets.
It adds that any business or organisation wanting to build gender-neutral amenities is free to do so.
On puberty blockers, the lines closely echo Wilson’s own media releases. They accuse the Carroll Labor government of allowing children to be prescribed life-altering hormone suppressants while experts remain divided on the treatment.
Candidates were urged to tell voters, without hesitation, that biological sex matters. They were also told to say that women and girls deserve access to female-only toilets and change rooms in privacy and with dignity.
The timing is no accident. The scripts were circulated after One Nation pledged to stop transgender women from using female bathrooms, and amid a federal government review of puberty blockers.
The gender debate has become a live electoral battlefield, and the Coalition has stepped in decisively.
Beyond the culture wars, every daily briefing comes with a fact sheet built to defeat the dreaded “gotcha” question.
The fact sheet lists the Reserve Bank of Australia cash rate and the latest unemployment figure, which is tracked by the Australian Bureau of Statistics. It also lists the cost of a dozen eggs, two litres of milk and a litre of unleaded petrol.
Recent history explains why. On day one of the 2022 federal campaign, then-opposition leader Anthony Albanese could not tell reporters the cash rate or the unemployment rate.
He later admitted the stumble was a mistake.
Three years later, Peter Dutton was caught out during a televised debate. He guessed a dozen eggs cost $4.20, when Woolworths was charging $8.80.
Both moments became defining clips of their campaigns. Wilson’s team is clearly determined that no Victorian Liberal will produce the next one.
That caution runs through the whole operation. Wilson has been the dominant face of the campaign, while most of her colleagues have stayed largely out of sight.
There have been occasional gambles.
Wilson made an unscripted visit to a Wodonga pub popular with One Nation voters, and she handed out how-to-vote cards at an early voting centre in Kew.
Otherwise, only trusted media performers such as frontbenchers Brad Battin and James Newbury have been regularly sent out, along with some joint press conferences with local candidates.
With the Coalition ahead in the polls, the strategy is plain: protect the lead.
Fear of being caught on tape has also shaped the campaign.
A Liberal source, speaking anonymously to describe private discussions, said candidates have been told repeatedly in meetings that volunteers from rival parties could be covertly recording them at voting booths.
That warning comes from experience. In October, Sunbury Liberal hopeful Simmone Cottom was caught on tape encouraging voters to back One Nation for the Legislative Council.
Ms Cottom has since expressed regret over what she said.
Then there is Paul Lindemann. The party dumped him as its Williamstown candidate after The Age exposed offensive posts about Indigenous people on a burner Facebook account.
He is now running as an independent.
Last Wednesday, footage emerged of Lindemann chasing a man he accused of defacing his corflutes. Lindemann subsequently took the matter to Victoria Police.
By Thursday morning, campaign headquarters had a scripted reply ready in case voters asked whether candidates knew about the “citizen’s arrest”. The script says the campaign was told, while Lindemann was still its candidate, that he had caught someone vandalising signs and referred it to police.
Anything further, it says, is now a matter for him alone. The briefing misspelled his name twice.
On Friday came another script. A volunteer for the party in Dandenong had used racist slurs.
Candidates were instructed to condemn the remarks as appalling and racist, and to stress that the person was not a party member and would be barred from volunteering again.
Analysis: What This Means for Australia
The leak exposes a deeper truth about modern Australian politics. Campaigns are now run less as contests of ideas and more as exercises in risk control.
For voters, that carries real social consequences.
When a candidate recites a centrally written line on an issue as sensitive as gender identity, residents lose the chance to hear what their would-be local member actually thinks.
The fact sheets reveal something too.
That candidates need written reminders of what eggs and milk cost shows how central the cost of living crisis has become to how voters judge politicians.
Families squeezed at the checkout are watching closely for leaders who seem out of touch.
The warnings about covert recording point to a more troubling shift. Polling booths have traditionally been relaxed, neighbourly spaces.
They are becoming sites of surveillance, where every conversation is potential ammunition and smartphones turn volunteers into opposition researchers.
For multicultural and Indigenous communities, the Lindemann and Dandenong episodes are a stark reminder that bigotry can surface even inside mainstream political machines, whatever the scripted condemnations that follow.
Political analysts say the documents show a party that has learned from its own mistakes and from the high-profile errors of others. Some warn the approach risks making candidates appear robotic.
Campaign insiders note that scripted discipline is now standard across the major parties.
They say the real difference this time is the Coalition’s decision to lean firmly into contested social issues, a move they believe is aimed at voters drifting towards One Nation.
Community advocates warn that reducing the transgender debate to one-line answers could leave vulnerable Victorians feeling like campaign props.
Whether the strategy holds will be decided at the ballot box, under the watch of the Victorian Electoral Commission. Until then, Coalition candidates will keep reading from the script.
