‘Tough Stance’ or ‘Cheap Attack’? Pauline Hanson Vows to Slash Refugee Intake by 90 Per Cent and Axe Parent Visas as Penny Wong Accuses One Nation of ‘Dividing Australians’
- One Nation would cut Australia’s annual refugee places from 20,000 to just 2,000 and abolish the permanent parent visa entirely if it held power.
- Pauline Hanson claims the plan would save taxpayers more than $140 billion over a decade, citing a lifetime cost of more than half a million dollars per humanitarian entrant.
- Foreign Minister Penny Wong openly disputed Hanson’s figures, warning that whenever the One Nation leader speaks, “you always have to check” what is actually being said.
- Advocates branded the policy a “predictable and cheap” swipe at the nation’s newest arrivals, as the issue looms over the upcoming Victorian state election.
Thousands of people fleeing war and persecution could find Australia’s door all but closed under a sweeping new migration blueprint unveiled by One Nation.
The promise is blunt. The numbers are staggering.
And the political fallout was immediate.
Pauline Hanson has reignited one of the most divisive debates in Australian public life, pledging to shrink the humanitarian program by nine-tenths and tear up a visa pathway that has allowed migrant families to bring elderly parents here permanently.
Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, the One Nation leader described the package as a “tough” response to what she framed as an unsustainable burden on the public purse.
Under the plan, Australia’s refugee allocation would plummet from 20,000 places each year to only 2,000. Hanson insists the country would still sit above the OECD average for refugees accepted per head of population.
She argued each humanitarian entrant costs taxpayers roughly $500,000 over a lifetime, and said her concern lay with struggling Australians who are already “doing it tough”.
In her view, the nation should not be admitting people who cannot pay for their own bed or a hospital bed.
One Nation says its estimate, a lifetime figure of $523,000 per person, comes from Treasury modelling adjusted for inflation.
The original Treasury work, completed in December 2021, put the figure at $400,000, with around 90 per cent of that carried by the federal government.
The party also confirmed that arrivals from nations on the Albanese government’s “do not travel” list, including Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Somalia, would remain barred.
The permanent parent visa would be scrapped altogether.
Hanson stressed parents would not be locked out, but would need to be sponsored by their own families or visit on temporary visas, so that relatives rather than taxpayers foot the bill.
The announcement lands in an already crowded field. Labor has committed to holding the intake at 20,000 a year.
The Coalition, under Opposition Leader Angus Taylor, has promised to halve it to 10,000. One Nation’s proposal goes dramatically further than both.
It also arrives as Western nations rethink their own systems.
The United States and Canada have both tightened migration settings, with Canada pulling back on its parent visa program, giving Hanson a ready-made international precedent to point to.
But the OECD comparison at the heart of her pitch is murkier than it appears. Canada and Australia rank as the most generous refugee resettlement nations per capita, yet those rankings count only refugees resettled through the UNHCR process.
Countries such as Germany and the US take in large numbers of asylum seekers who arrive at their borders and seek protection. Those people largely fall outside the OECD resettlement figures, making those nations look far less generous on paper than they really are.
Analysis: What This Means for Australia
Strip away the slogans and this is a fight about money, fairness and national identity, all colliding against the backdrop of the cost of living crisis.
Hanson’s $140 billion savings claim is designed to resonate with households battling rising rents and grocery bills.
Yet economists routinely caution that lifetime-cost modelling captures spending but often struggles to account for the taxes, businesses and workforce contributions refugees and their children generate over decades.
On the security front, the policy leans heavily on existing travel warnings rather than new screening measures, raising questions about whether a blanket nationality ban would add meaningful protection or simply symbolic weight.
For communities, the stakes are deeply personal.
Scrapping the permanent parent visa would leave many migrant families weighing expensive private sponsorship against long separations from ageing mothers and fathers, a shift that could ripple through aged care arrangements and multicultural neighbourhoods across the country.
There is also the question of Australia’s standing abroad. A 90 per cent cut would mark a profound retreat from a resettlement role that has long been a pillar of the nation’s diplomatic reputation.
Penny Wong wasted no time going on the attack.
She said she did not accept Hanson’s figures and maintained that 20,000 places strikes the right balance, noting some nations take more refugees and some take fewer.
Wong pointed to a world in which more people are displaced than at any point since World War II, describing Australia’s contribution as very small. She dismissed the plan as “more of the same”, accusing One Nation of believing division is the best answer to the politics of the moment.
Taylor defended his own policy of halving the intake while acknowledging that some of the nation’s greatest citizens, including founders of extraordinarily successful businesses, arrived as refugees.
He said the priority must be ensuring newcomers share Australian values.
Shadow Treasurer Tim Wilson was more dismissive, telling News24 he did not take One Nation’s announcements seriously because they keep changing, and saw no substantial policy work behind the headline numbers.
Greens leader David Shoebridge accused One Nation and both major parties of a “race to the bottom” on refugees, describing Hanson’s plan as the latest shameful chapter in a decades-long campaign.
The Asylum Seeker Resource Centre’s deputy chief executive, Jana Favero, said Australians were tired of politicians blaming new arrivals, insisting a smaller humanitarian intake would make Victorians neither richer nor safer.
Political analysts say the timing is no accident, with migration emerging as a potent weapon ahead of the Victorian poll. Policy observers believe One Nation is betting that voter frustration over housing and living costs will outweigh concerns about humanitarian obligations.
Immigration specialists warn, however, that headline cuts rarely survive contact with the reality of immigration policy, where international commitments, labour shortages and family reunification pressures pull in competing directions.
What is certain is that the debate is far from over, and Hanson has once again forced every party to show its hand.
