‘Get Tough’ Gamble: Jess Wilson Unveils $60 Million Plan to Turn Old Country Prison Into Boot Camp for Teen Offenders, but Critics Ask If It Works
- Victorian Opposition Leader Jess Wilson has put a $60 million price tag on a two-year trial sending offenders aged 14 to 17 to a farm-style boot camp at the former Dhurringile Prison.
- Teenagers would follow a strict daily routine of farm labour, cleaning, cooking, laundry and schooling, with possible trade training linked to the housing industry.
- Wilson faced tough questions on live television about a Queensland boot camp that was scrapped after an evaluation found almost two in three participants reoffended.
- With polling showing crime has overtaken housing as Victoria’s top voter concern, both major parties are spending big on youth justice before the November 28 election.
Twelve days.
That is all that stands between Victorians and a state election increasingly dominated by one question: who can stop the young offenders whose crimes have left many families afraid in their own homes?
The Coalition’s answer is blunt. Take teenagers who have broken the law, send them to a rural compound, and keep them busy from dawn to dusk.
The question now is whether it will work, or whether Victorians are being sold an idea that has already failed elsewhere.
Opposition Leader Jess Wilson revealed on Monday that her party’s youth offender boot camp would cost taxpayers $60 million and run as a two-year pilot.
She was pressed hard on whether the plan would actually reduce reoffending when she appeared on Channel Seven’s Sunrise.
Under the proposal, the former Dhurringile Prison near Murchison, in the state’s north, would be redeveloped to house young offenders. Wilson said the site was already standing and needed to be made fit for purpose, conceding that significant upgrades would be needed.
Courts would have the power to send teenagers aged 14 to 17 to the facility. Once there, they would follow a regimented daily schedule built around farm work, cleaning, cooking, doing laundry and attending classes.
The boot camp forms part of the Coalition’s broader $100 million Safer Communities Plan. Wilson said the two-year trial would give a future government time to judge whether the approach was delivering results.
She also flagged a vocational component, suggesting the program could partner with Victoria’s housing sector to teach construction skills.
She framed it as a chance to pull children off a path of crime, give them the tools to rebuild their lives, and get tough on offending at the same time.
But host Nat Barr went straight to the evidence.
She pointed to Queensland’s experience.
That state’s youth boot camp program was shut down in 2015 after an independent evaluation by KPMG found 63.5 per cent of young people sentenced to it went on to reoffend.
Asked what proof she had that Victoria’s version would succeed, Wilson turned the spotlight on the government. She said seven out of ten young people who go through Labor’s current youth justice programs offend or reoffend within six months of finishing.
She insisted similar models had worked around the world and argued that giving young people practical, job-ready skills was a proven way to keep them out of trouble once they leave detention.
The timing is no accident.
Fear of youth crime has become a defining issue in Victoria, fuelled by a run of home invasions, car thefts and violent incidents involving teenagers that have dominated headlines and community forums.
Freshwater Strategy polling commissioned by the Herald Sun found 48 per cent of voters named crime as an issue likely to sway their vote. That put it well ahead of housing affordability, cited by 37 per cent, in a state where housing pressure has been severe.
The boot camp is just one part of the Coalition’s law-and-order pitch.
The party has also promised to recruit 3,000 extra police officers, bring in tougher sentencing laws for adults, and introduce a one-strike bail rule for serious offences.
Labor is not standing still.
The Allan Government has pledged $204 million for mandatory therapeutic detention for young offenders, combining secure custody with education, drug and alcohol treatment and mental health support.
It means Victorians face a stark choice between two philosophies. One leans on discipline, routine and hard work.
The other puts treatment and rehabilitation inside locked walls.
Analysis: What This Means for Australia
What happens in Victoria rarely stays in Victoria. As the second most populous state, its youth justice policy is watched closely by other governments wrestling with the same pressures.
For communities, the stakes are personal. Families who have been burgled or confronted on the street want to know offenders will face consequences.
But they also want assurances those same teenagers will not return to their suburbs more hardened and more dangerous.
The law enforcement implications are significant. A one-strike bail rule and 3,000 extra officers would likely mean more arrests and more young people coming before the courts.
That puts added strain on a system that must find somewhere to send them.
There is also the matter of money. At $60 million for a two-year pilot, the boot camp is a costly experiment.
If reoffending rates mirror those in Queensland, taxpayers could be footing the bill for a program that leaves public safety no better off.
Yet doing nothing has a cost too. Repeat offending drives insurance premiums, policing costs and court backlogs.
It also erodes something harder to measure: public confidence that the state can keep people safe.
Criminologists have long debated boot camps across Australia and overseas, and data from bodies such as the Australian Institute of Criminology and the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare has repeatedly highlighted how hard it is to break the cycle of youth reoffending.
Law enforcement insiders warn that discipline alone rarely changes behaviour.
Many young offenders come from backgrounds marked by trauma, family breakdown, substance abuse or disengagement from school, and programs that ignore these factors risk becoming a revolving door.
Youth justice observers believe the strongest element of the Coalition’s plan may be the vocational training.
A genuine pathway into construction work, particularly while Victoria needs tradespeople, could give teenagers something many have never had: a reason to stay out of trouble.
Policy analysts say the real test will be what happens after release.
Without ongoing support, housing and supervision, gains made inside any facility can disappear quickly once a young person returns to the same streets and the same peer groups.
Political observers note that both parties are betting heavily on one issue.
With crime topping voter concerns, the party judged most credible on community safety could hold a decisive edge when Victorians head to the polls on November 28.
For now, the Dhurringile site stands empty near Murchison. Whether it becomes a turning point for troubled teenagers or another costly lesson may depend on how Victorians vote.
