‘Nobody Believes a Word You Say’: Humiliated Premier Ben Carroll Polls Just Seven Per Cent as Jess Wilson Mocks Him Over ‘Voldemort’ Predecessors and Victoria’s Only Election Debate Exposes a State That Has Stopped Listening
- Premier Ben Carroll was picked as the winner by just seven per cent of undecided voters, finishing dead last behind the Greens and One Nation.
- Opposition Leader Jess Wilson taunted Carroll for refusing to name Daniel Andrews or Jacinta Allan, telling him they were “not Voldemort”, then hit him with Labor’s $200 billion debt.
- One Nation’s Warren Pickering compared Victoria to “Gotham City” and vowed to send offenders to a NSW supermax prison if Victorian jails are full.
- A bearded schoolteacher drew the loudest applause of the night by telling all four leaders that voters no longer believe anything politicians say.
He stood up, looked the four most powerful political figures in Victoria in the eye, and told them the brutal truth.
Nobody believes them any more.
The schoolteacher, identified only as Billy, received the only rousing ovation of the night. Not the Premier.
Not the woman tipped to replace him. A voter.
That single moment captured a state in the grip of a crisis that goes far deeper than who wins on polling day. It is a collapse of faith, and on Tuesday night it was laid bare.
Victoria’s one and only leaders’ debate of the 2026 state election unfolded at the Sofitel in Melbourne, where 100 undecided voters packed a room for the so-called “People’s Forum”, co-hosted by News24 and the Herald Sun and moderated by Kieran Gilbert.
On stage were Labor Premier Ben Carroll, Liberal Opposition Leader Jess Wilson, Greens leader Ellen Sandell and One Nation’s Victorian leader Warren Pickering.
The verdict, when the audience was surveyed on the way out, was savage. Wilson was judged the winner by 39 per cent.
Sandell came second with 25 per cent, and Pickering third on 16 per cent. Thirteen per cent couldn’t decide.
Carroll scraped together just seven per cent.
The sharpest blow landed early, when Wilson needled the Premier for repeatedly avoiding the names of the two Labor leaders who came before him. Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan, she reminded him, were not Voldemort.
Carroll hit back that he could say their names just as easily as Wilson could say Jeff Kennett’s. Wilson didn’t miss a beat, simply replying: “Jeff Kennett.”
Carroll, for all the sparring, never uttered either name.
When the Premier claimed Liberal policies did not “stack up” and would force cuts to hospital funding to pay down debt, Wilson delivered what the Herald Sun branded her “Julia Gillard moment”, declaring she would not be lectured on costings by a government that had piled up $200 billion in debt.
Pickering, meanwhile, painted a grim portrait of a state overrun by crime, likening Victoria to Gotham City.
He said he did not give a “d**n” if prisons were full, insisting lawbreakers would go to jail, even if that meant shipping them to the supermax facility being built in New South Wales.
The campaign had, until Tuesday, been a sluggish affair.
Two weeks in, Labor has been bleeding support in the polls, while the Coalition has focused largely on avoiding self-inflicted wounds as it heads towards what looks like a comfortable victory.
Early voting opened on Wednesday.
Even the debate’s line-up became a battleground. Sandell was only added late, after Carroll and Wilson clashed over whether Pickering should be given a podium.
And there will be no rematch.
Carroll and Wilson could not agree on terms for a free-to-air television debate, meaning Tuesday’s forum was the only time voters will see the leaders go head to head.
Analysis: What This Means for Australia
The real story of the night was not the zingers. It was the anger in the room, and what it signals for social cohesion well beyond Victoria’s borders.
A four-way stage, as Sandell pointed out herself, tells you everything about how politics is changing. The old two-party contest is fracturing.
Voters squeezed by the cost of living crisis and locked out of the housing crisis are drifting towards the Greens on one side and One Nation on the other.
Sandell tapped directly into that resentment, accusing all three rivals of being bought: Labor by gambling interests, the Liberals by property developers, and One Nation by mining billionaire Gina Rinehart, who she claimed was effectively writing the party’s policy.
If you can’t afford groceries, rent or a home, she told voters, look at who funds these parties.
For community safety, the stakes are just as high. Pickering’s pledge to export prisoners interstate raises serious questions about capacity, costs and cooperation between states.
Wilson’s warning about rocks being thrown at police during pro-Palestinian rallies in the CBD clashed with Sandell’s defence of peaceful protest, and her distinction between antisemitism, which she called unacceptable, and criticism of the Israeli government’s conduct.
In a striking twist, Pickering sided with Sandell, saying politicians should not decide who gets to protest and calling One Nation a flagbearer for free speech.
Sandell went further, labelling protest permits an authoritarian move.
Economically, the uncertainty is enormous.
Wilson refused to rule out scrapping the multibillion-dollar Suburban Rail Loop, telling Gilbert that was “exactly what the review is for” once the Coalition sees the signed contracts.
She also clashed with Sandell over treaty, claiming it goes further than the Voice and undermines parliament. Sandell accused her of lying to Victorians.
On net zero, Wilson resisted Pickering’s pressure, saying she was guided by “practicality”, not “ideology”.
Carroll conceded Labor had made mistakes over 12 years in power, but leaned hard on his record: 121 new schools, record NAPLAN results, the nation’s highest-paid teachers and 17,000 extra nurses.
He repeatedly cited his decision to call a royal commission into alleged corruption on government construction sites, describing it as one of the hardest things he has done.
Sandell was unmoved, pressing him on public sector cuts and wage battles with nurses, teachers, council workers and firefighters.
Political analysts say the Premier’s seven per cent result should alarm Labor strategists nationally, warning that once voters tune out a long-serving government, policy achievements barely register.
Campaign insiders believe Wilson achieved exactly what a frontrunner needs, refusing to take the bait and walking away unscathed.
Observers of the minor parties suggest Sandell’s strong showing, in what was clearly hostile territory, points to growing appetite for leaders willing to attack everyone, and warn a hung parliament remains possible.
Sandell, for her part, said Greens values were “quite far apart” from the Coalition’s.
Social researchers warn that the applause for Billy should be the loudest alarm bell of all. When a teacher’s plea for honesty outshines every leader on stage, the trust in politics deficit is no longer a talking point.
It is a threat to the system itself.
Victorians head to the ballot box with the Victorian Electoral Commission already open for early voting. Whether they are listening to their leaders is another matter entirely.
